Stream periphyton response to grazing and changes in phosphorus concentration

Abstract

Grazing by the large caddisfly larva, Dicosmoecus gilvipes (Trichoptera; Limnephilidae), drastically reduced periphyton biomass in laboratory channels at a current velocity of 20 cm s−1. Reduction in biomass as chl a and AFDW ranged from 88 to 93% and 82 to 85%, respectively. On average, grazing rate increased with in-channel SRP (soluble reactive phosphorus) content from 6 to 10 µg 1−1. Grazing rates averaged 25.9–29.3 µg chl a m−2 d−1 and 10.8–12.2 µg chl a mg−1 d−1 based on area and grazer biomass, respectively, with most variability among treatments being due to the grazing effect. Grazing tended to shift the algal community increasingly to filamentous blue-green algae regardless of enrichment. After three weeks, Phormidium comprised over 61% of the community in grazed treatments but only 35% in ungrazed treatments. The stalked diatom Gomphonema comprised only 4% of the grazed community, but 11% in the three ungrazed channels with similar values for Scenedesmus. A model that includes grazing was calibrated to the data and produced a reasonable expectation of periphyton biomass over a range in SRP concentrations. While the model with constant grazer abundance predicts a gradually increasing grazed biomass as SRP increases, grazer production in natural streams may actually increase to accommodate the increased food production.