Strategies for the Optimal Control of Dust Emissions from Unpaved Roads

Abstract

Travel on unpaved public roads is the single largest anthropogenic source of emissions of airborne particles in the U.S. The average impact of this source on average annual mean total suspended particulate (TSP) concentrations varies from 0.05 μg/m3 (Alaska) to 11 μg/m3 (Pennsylvania). When compared by contributions to the variance in state to state TSP levels, their impact is as great as the impact of emissions from all conventional sources. Common emission control methods include paving, oiling, speed reduction, watering, and application of calcium chloride. Total annual emissions are, in most cases, most economically reduced by either speed control or paving, with expected average control costs of less than $0.50/lb of emissions reductions. For most roads with average daily traffic flows above 100 vehicles per day, paving is shown to control emissions at average costs of less than $0.05/lb. In some situations, the costs of paving are more than offset by reductions in maintenance costs. Thus it would appear that, even accounting for the order of magnitude lower impact on statewide average concentration per ton of particles emitted from open sources, control of dust emissions from unpaved roads offers an economical means for reducing ambient TSP levels.