Steam and air oxidation behaviour of thermal spray chromium carbide-based composite coatings

Abstract

Thermal spray chromium carbide-based composites have been widely used industrially because of their superior oxidation resistance at elevated temperatures compared to other metal matrix composite coatings. In this work, the serviceability of HVOF sprayed coatings from an atomized chromium carbide-based feedstock (Cr23C6-40NiCr) was compared with those from a conventional Cr3C2-25NiCr agglomerated and sintered feedstock. Coatings were exposed to 540 °C and 610 °C for 168 h in both air and steam environments. These conditions are indicative of industrial power plant working conditions to assess their real-time performance. Quantitative Rietveld analysis of the Cr23C6-40NiCr coating XRD patterns indicated a comparable concentration of Cr23C6 in both the powder and coating, implying minimal carbide dissolution. However, the Cr3C2 content in the conventional Cr3C2-25NiCr coating was markedly reduced compared to the initial powder composition, indicating that carbide dissolution occurred to a greater extent. Air oxidation led to the formation of coarse surface oxide, due to the initial formation of Ni-based oxides before a continuous Cr2O3 layer could develop underneath. A notably finer and more uniform oxidized surface composed only of Cr2O3 was formed during steam treatment across both coating types. More importantly, the oxide scale was intact and crack-free in Cr23C6-40NiCr compared to Cr3C2-25NiCr. Moreover, despite Cr23C6 being the main carbide phase and the high binder content (40%NiCr), the microhardness of the Cr23C6-40NiCr coating was comparable to that of the conventional Cr3C2-25NiCr coating, both in the as-sprayed and heat exposed states.