Stand-scale responses of forest-floor small mammal populations to varying size, number, and location of retention tree patches

Abstract

Retention forestry, the practice of maintaining stand legacies in harvested forests, is used to create more complex forest structure and positive biodiversity outcomes in managed forests. However, the relative effectiveness of different retention strategies at increasing forest structural complexity and populations of dependent wildlife species is not well understood. We used an experimental study to evaluate changes in the population density of three small mammal species in response to different size and location (riparian or upland) of retention tree patches within harvested forests in the Pacific Northwest, USA. We further assessed whether small mammal density varied in relation to differences in structural complexity within retention patches among experimental retention stands. Within stands, deer mice (Peromyscus spp.) population density did not differ between retention and harvested areas (β = −0.05, SE = 0.06), Townsend’s chipmunk (Neotamias townsendii) density was higher in retention compared to clearcut areas (β = 1.61, SE = 0.10), and creeping vole (Microtus oregoni) density was highest in clearcut areas (β = −0.68, SE = 0.10). At the stand-scale, deer mouse density and chipmunk density were lowest in stands with large upland patches of retention (mean = 83, SD = 28 trees) and highest in stands with multiple small patches of upland retention (mean = 8, SD = 2 trees). Creeping vole density followed the opposite pattern, highest in stands with large upland patches and lowest in stands with multiple small patches. Densities of each species were intermediate in stands where at least a portion of the retention trees were connected to forested riparian buffers. Relating the density of each species to structural complexity within stands revealed that Townsend’s chipmunk density increased with increasing retention tree blowdown (β = 0.39, SE = 0.08), a proxy for downed wood resources, whereas creeping vole density decreased (β = −0.51, SE = 0.12), and deer mice density did not change consistently (β = 0.00, SE = 0.08). Furthermore, retention tree mortality was highest in the experimental treatment with several small patches and lowest in the treatment with a single large patch. Our results demonstrate that adopting dispersed retention patch patterns increases the abundance of small mammals in managed, early-seral forests in the Pacific Northwest. This relationship is at least partly mediated through higher levels of structural complexity within small retention patches caused by increased retention tree blowdown compared to larger patches.