Staging laparotomy and splenectomy in early Hodgkin's disease: No therapeutic benefit

Abstract

In a prospective randomized study of treatment for early-stage Hodgkin's disease presenting above the diaphragm, 76 patients had staging by laparotomy (Group I) and 28 had staging by closed techniques (Group II). Treatment consisted of involved-field radiotherapy alone (44 patients), involved-field radiotherapy followed by chemotherapy (38 patients), total nodal radiotherapy atone (15 patients), or total nodal radiotherapy followed by chemotherapy (seven patients). On presentation, both groups had similar clinical features and similar treatment distribution. With similar follow-up (87 months), no significant differences in remission or survival were observed between Groups I and II: remission 59 versus 68 percent; survival 74 versus 92 percent; p value 0.27 and 0.09, respectively. Multiple areas of relapse were more frequently observed in Group I (11 of 32 had relapse) as compared with Group II (none of nine had relapse, p < 0.082). In Group I, relapse in the abdomen was observed as an isolated event or as part of disseminated relapse in 12 percent of patients compared with 3 percent (one patient) in Group II with abdominal relapse alone. Seven patients in Group I and two patients in Group II died with Hodgkin's disease. Six other patients in Group I died with complete remission of non-Hodgkin's lymphoma (one patient), leukoencephalopathy (one patient), sepsis during chemotherapy (two patients), myocardial infarction (one patient), and cerebrovascular accident (one patient). Three other patients in this group had other secondary malignancies successfully controlled (histiocytic lymphoma, squamous cell carcinoma of the cervix, and malignant schwannoma). No second primary lesions or death with complete remission were observed in Group II. Staging laparotomy with splenectomy in early-stage Hodgkin's disease did not improve the duration of remission or survival or decrease the number of abdominal relapses compared with closed staging.