Stable zirconium isotopic fractionation during alkaline magma differentiation: Implications for the differentiation of continental crust

Abstract

Stable Zr isotopes have shown great potential in tracing magma differentiation. However, it remains unclear if different magmatic systems have similar Zr isotopic evolution patterns. Here we report high-precision Zr isotopic compositions of the well-defined Shidao alkaline complex (SAC), eastern China, which show small but important differences from the Hekla tholeiitic volcanic suite, Iceland. The SAC comprises monzodioritic, syenitic, and granitic intrusions with high alkali contents, representing a magmatic suite produced by various degrees of cognate magma differentiation. From mafic to felsic samples, the Zr concentrations and Zr/Hf ratios increase first and then decrease significantly at the inflection of ∼65 wt% SiO2, suggesting zircon saturation started at ∼65 wt% SiO2 during magma differentiation. The δ94Zr values (permil deviation of the 94Zr/90Zr ratio from IPGP-Zr standard) remain nearly constant at ca. +0.01‰ in samples with SiO2 < 65 wt% but then gradually increase with SiO2 in more felsic samples (from +0.05 to +0.63‰), indicating that the Zr isotope fractionation also occurs at ∼65 wt% SiO2. The Shidao alkaline and Hekla tholeiitic suites show zircon saturation at SiO2 ∼ 65 wt%, but their Zr isotopic evolution paths differ. The alkaline suite increases more slowly in δ94Zr compared to the tholeiitic one, with the former reaching the same δ94Zr value at SiO2 higher by ∼5 wt%. Our findings represent the first observation of differences in Zr isotopic evolution from different igneous systems (tholeiitic versus alkaline), which should be considered when interpreting Zr isotopic data of samples out of context, such as detrital zircons or sedimentary samples. Based on the more sluggish Zr isotopic enrichment in the alkaline series than the tholeiitic one, we re-interpret the Zr isotopic composition of the upper continental crust, which may simply be not felsic enough to be isotopically heavier.