Stabilization of topological insulator emerging from electron correlations on honeycomb lattice and its possible relevance in twisted bilayer graphene

Magic-angle twisted bilayer graphene displays at different fillings of the four flat bands lying around the charge neutrality point a wealth of notable phases that include magnetic Chern insulators, whose magnetization is mostly of an orbital nature and contiguous superconducting domes. Such a rich phase diagram is explained through the positive interplay of Coulomb repulsion and the electron coupling to a twofold optical mode that corresponds to Kekul\'e distortions localized into the small AA stacked regions of the moir\'e supercells. A static distortion stabilizes, at any integer filling of the flat bands, valence-bond insulators that carry finite Chern number away from charge neutrality. Similarly, a dynamic distortion that resonates between the two lattice vibrations leads to resonating-valence-bond topological insulators with built-in chiral d-wave pairs that have finite Chern number equal to the angular momentum, and thus are prone to turn superconducting upon doping away from integer filling.

The discovery of the quantum spin Hall effect and topological insulators more than a decade ago has revolutionized modern condensed matter physics. Today, the field of topological states of matter is one of the most active and fruitful research areas for both experimentalists and theorists. The physics of topological insulators is typically well described by band theory and systems of non-interacting fermions. In contrast, several of the most fascinating effects in condensed matter physics merely exist due to electron–electron interactions, examples include unconventional superconductivity, the Kondo effect, and the Mott–Hubbard transition.The aim of this review article is to give an overview of the manifold directions which emerge when topological bandstructures and correlation physics interfere and compete. These include the study of the stability of topological bandstructures and correlated topological insulators. Interaction-induced topological phases such as the topological Kondo insulator provide another exciting topic. More exotic states of matter such as topological Mott insulator and fractional Chern insulators only exist due to the interplay of topology and strong interactions and do not have any bandstructure analogue. Eventually the relation between topological bandstructures and frustrated quantum magnetism in certain transition metal oxides is emphasized.

Topological insulators are found in materials that have elements with strong spin orbit interaction. However, electron Coulomb repulsion also potentially generates the topological insulators as well as Chern insulators by the mechanism of spontaneous symmetry breaking, which is called topological Mott insulators. The quantum criticality of the transition to the topological Mott insulators from zero-gap semiconductors follows unconventional universality distinct from the Landau-Ginzburg-Wilson scenario. On the pyrochlore lattice, the interplay of the electron correlation and the spin orbit interaction provides us in a rich phase diagram not only with simple topological insulators but also with Weyl semimetal and topologically distinct antiferromagnetic phases. Magnetic domain wall of the all-in-all-out type antiferromagnetic order offers a promising candidate of magnetically controlled transport, because, even when the Weyl points disappears, the domain wall maintains robust gapless excitations with Fermi surfaces around it embedded in the bulk insulator and bears uniform magnetization simultaneously. The ingap state is protected by a mechanism similar to the solitons in polyacetylene. Puzzling experimental results of pyrochlore iridates are favorably compared with the prediction of the domain wall theory.

How Magical Is Magic-Angle Graphene?

The possibility of realizing topological insulators by spontaneous formation\nof electronic superstructure is theoretically investigated in a minimal\ntwo-orbital model including both the spin-orbit coupling and electron\ncorrelations on a triangular lattice. Using the mean-field approximation, we\nshow that the model exhibits several different types of charge ordered\ninsulators, where the charge disproportionation forms a honeycomb or kagome\nsuperstructure. We find that the charge ordered insulators in the presence of\nstrong spin-orbit coupling can be topological insulators showing quantized spin\nHall conductivity. Their band gap is dependent on electron correlations as well\nas the spin-orbit coupling, and even vanishes with showing the massless Dirac\ndispersion at the transition to a trivial charge ordered insulator. Our results\nsuggest a new route to realize and control topological states of quantum matter\nby the interplay between the spin-orbit coupling and electron correlations.\n

We investigate the phase diagram of spinless fermions with nearest and next-nearest neighbour density-density interactions on the honeycomb lattice at half-filling. Using Exact Diagonalization techniques of the full Hamiltonian and constrained subspaces, combined with a careful choice of finite-size clusters, we determine the different charge orderings that occur for large interactions. In this regime we find a two-sublattice N\'eel-like state, a charge modulated state with a tripling of the unit cell, a zig-zag phase and a novel charge ordered states with a 12 site unit cells we call N\'eel domain wall crystal, as well as a region of phase separation for attractive interactions. A sizeable region of the phase diagram is classically degenerate, but it remains unclear whether an order-by-disorder mechanism will lift the degeneracy. For intermediate repulsion we find evidence for a Kekul\'e or plaquette bond-order wave phase. We also investigate the possibility of a spontaneous Chern insulator phase (dubbed topological Mott insulator), as previously put forward by several mean-field studies. Although we are unable to detect convincing evidence for this phase based on energy spectra and order parameters, we find an enhancement of current-current correlations with the expected spatial structure compared to the non-interacting situation. While for the studied $t{-}V_1{-}V_2$ model the phase transition to the putative topological Mott insulator is preempted by the phase transitions to the various ordered states, our findings might hint at the possibility for a topological Mott insulator in an enlarged Hamiltonian parameter space, where the competing phases are suppressed.

Recent Advances in Topological Quantum Materials by Angle-Resolved Photoemission Spectroscopy

Topological Mott insulator by block spin phenomenology

We use a real-space slave-rotor theory of the physics of topological Mott insulators, using the Kane-Mele-Hubbard model as an example, and show that a topological gap in the Green function zeros corresponds to a gap in the bulk spinon spectrum and implies a gapless band of edge zeros and a spinon edge mode. We then consider an interface between a topological Mott insulator and a conventional topological insulator showing how the spinon edge mode of the topological Mott insulator combines with the spin part of the conventional electron topological edge state, leaving a non-Fermi liquid edge mode described by a gapless propagating holon and gapped spinon state. Our work demonstrates the physical meaning of Green function zeros and shows that interfaces between conventional and Mott topological insulators are a rich source of new physics.

We show that for magic-angle twisted bilayer graphene (TBG) away from charge neutrality, although quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) simulations suffer from the sign problem, the computational complexity is at most polynomial at certain integer fillings. For even integer fillings, this polynomial complexity survives even if an extra inter-valley attractive interaction is introduced, on top of Coulomb repulsions. This observation allows us to simulate magic-angle twisted bilayer graphene and to obtain accurate phase diagram and dynamical properties. At the chiral limit and filling $\nu=1$, the simulations reveal a thermodynamic transition separating metallic state and a $C=1$ correlated Chern insulator -- topological Mott insulator (TMI) -- and the pseudogap spectrum slightly above the transition temperature. The ground state excitation spectra of the TMI exhibit a spin-valley U(4) Goldstone mode and a time reversal restoring excitonic gap smaller than the single particle gap. These results are qualitatively consistent with the recent experimental findings at zero-field and $\nu=1$ filling in $h$-BN nonaligned TBG.

Topological insulators have become one of the most active research areas in condensed matter physics. This article reviews progress on the topic of electronic correlation effects in the two-dimensional case, with a focus on systems with intrinsic spin–orbit coupling and numerical results. Topics addressed include an introduction to the noninteracting case, an overview of theoretical models, correlated topological band insulators, interaction-driven phase transitions, topological Mott insulators and fractional topological states, correlation effects on helical edge states, and topological invariants of interacting systems.

Strong spin–orbit coupling fosters exotic electronic states such as topological insulators and superconductors, but the combination of strong spin–orbit and strong electron–electron interactions is just beginning to be understood. Central to this emerging area are the 5d transition metal iridium oxides. Here, in the pyrochlore iridate Pr2Ir2O7, we identify a non-trivial state with a single-point Fermi node protected by cubic and time-reversal symmetries, using a combination of angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy and first-principles calculations. Owing to its quadratic dispersion, the unique coincidence of four degenerate states at the Fermi energy, and strong Coulomb interactions, non-Fermi liquid behaviour is predicted, for which we observe some evidence. Our discovery implies that Pr2Ir2O7 is a parent state that can be manipulated to produce other strongly correlated topological phases, such as topological Mott insulator, Weyl semimetal, and quantum spin and anomalous Hall states.

The phase diagram of the strongly correlated Hubbard model with intrinsic spin-orbit coupling on the honeycomb lattice is explored here. We obtain the low-energy effective model describing the spin degree of freedom. The resulting model is then studied by the Schwinger boson and Schwinger fermion approaches. The Schwinger boson method elucidates the boundary between the spin liquid phase and the magnetically ordered phases, Neel order, and incommensurate Neel order. Increasing the strength of the spin-orbit coupling is shown to narrow the width of the spin liquid region. The Schwinger fermion approach sheds further light on the nature of the spin liquid phase. We obtained three different candidates for the spin liquid phase within the mean-field approximation, namely, the gapless spin liquid, topological Mott insulator (fractionalized topological insulator), and chiral spin liquid phases. However, we argue that the gauge fluctuations and the instanton effect may suppress the first two spin liquids, while the chiral spin liquid is stable against gauge fluctuations due to its nontrivial topology.

Moiré is More: Access to New Properties of Two-Dimensional Layered Materials

We study possible quantum $U(1)$ spin liquids in three dimensions with time-reversal symmetry. We find a total of 7 families of such $U(1)$ spin liquids, distinguished by the properties of their emergent electric/magnetic charges. We show how these spin liquids are related to each other. Two of these classes admit nontrivial protected surface states which we describe. We show how to access all of the 7 spin liquids through slave particle (parton) constructions. We also provide intuitive loop gas descriptions of their ground state wave functions. One of these phases is the `topological Mott insulator' conventionally described as a topological insulator of an emergent fermionic `spinon'. We show that this phase admits a remarkable dual description as a topological insulator of emergent fermionic magnetic monopoles. This results in a new (possibly natural) surface phase for the topological Mott insulator and a new slave particle construction. We describe some of the continuous quantum phase transitions between the different $U(1)$ spin liquids. Each of these seven families of states admits a finer distinction in terms of their surface properties which we determine by combining these spin liquids with symmetry protected topological phases. We discuss lessons for materials such as pyrochlore quantum spin ices which may harbor a $U(1)$ spin liquid. We suggest the topological Mott insulator as a possible ground state in some range of parameters for the quantum spin ice Hamiltonian.