Spin−Spin Contributions to the Zero-Field Splitting Tensor in Organic Triplets, Carbenes and BiradicalsA Density Functional and Ab Initio Study

Abstract

An evaluation study for the direct dipolar electron spin-spin (SS) contribution to the zero-field splitting (ZFS) tensor in electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy is presented. Calculations were performed on a wide variety of organic systems where the SS contribution to the ZFS dominates over the second-order spin-orbit coupling (SOC) contribution. Calculations were performed using (hybrid) density functional theory (DFT), as well as complete active space self-consistent field (CASSCF) wave functions. In the former case, our implementation is an approximation, because we use the two-particle reduced spin-density matrix of the noninteracting reference system. In the latter case, the SS contribution is approximated by a mean-field method which, nevertheless, gives accurate results, compared to the approximation free computation of the SS part in a CASSCF framework. For the case of the triplet dioxygen molecule, it was shown that restricted open-shell density functional theory (RODFT), as well as CASSCF, can provide accurate spin-spin couplings while spin-unrestricted DFT leads to much larger errors. Furthermore, 15 organic radicals, including several 1,3 and 1,5 diradicals, dinitroxide biradicals, and even a chlorophyll a model system, were examined as test cases to demonstrate the accuracy and efficiency of our approach within a DFT framework. Accurate D values with root-mean-square deviations of 0.0035 cm(-1) were obtained. Furthermore, all trends, including those due to substituent effects, were correctly reproduced. In a different set of calculations, the polyacenes benzene, naphthalene, anthracene, and tetracene were studied. Applying DFT, the absolute D values were noticeably underestimated, but it was possible to correctly reproduce the trend to smaller D values with larger size of the systems. Finally, it was demonstrated that our approach is also well-suited for the study of carbenes. The smaller organic radicals of this work were also studied, through the use of CASSCF wave functions. This was a special advantage in the case of the triplet polyacenes, where the CASSCF approach gave better results than the DFT method. In comparing spin-restricted and spin-unrestricted results, it was shown through a natural orbital analysis and comparison to high-level ab initio calculations that even small amounts of spin polarization introduced by the unrestricted calculations lead to large deviations between the unrestricted Kohn-Sham (UKS) and restricted open-shell Kohn-Sham (ROKS) approaches. It is challenging to understand why the ROKS results show much better correlation with the experimental data.