Spinal Bone Mineral Density in Premenopausal Vegetarian and Nonvegetarian Women: Cross-sectional and Prospective Comparisons

Abstract

Objective To compare spinal bone mineral density (BMD) and 1-year BMD change between premenopausal vegetarian and nonvegetarian women. Design Cross-sectional comparison of spinal BMD at baseline and prospective comparison of a subsample. Setting A western Canadian metropolitan area. Subjects/samples Healthy vegetarian (n=15 lacto-ovo-vegetarian, n=8 vegan) and nonvegetarian (n=22) women aged 20 to 40 years, with regular menstrual cycles and stable body weight completed baseline measurements. Twenty of these women (6 lacto-ovo-vegetarian, 5 vegan, 9 non-vegetarian) participated in repeat measurements at approximately 13 months. Statistical analyses performed Descriptive statistics, independent sample and paired t tests, 1-way analysis of variance, correlation analysis, and stepwise multiple regression were used to compare groups and to assess associations with BMD. Results At baseline, subjects were 27.2±5.1 years old. Vegetarians had lower body mass index (21.1±2.3 vs 22.7±1.9, P<.05) and percent body fat (24.0±5.5% vs 27.4±5.1%, P<.05); they also tended to have lower BMD (1.148±0.111 g/cm 2 vs 1.216±0.132 g/cm 2, P=.06), although this was not apparent with weight as a covariate ( P=.14). Baseline BMD was predicted by vitamin B-12 intake and total body fat ( R 2=.24, P=.001). Participants in the follow-up differed only in their being older than nonparticipants. Over 1 year, mean BMD increased significantly (1.1%): by diet group, non-vegetarians’ BMD increased but vegetarians’ BMD was unchanged. No other monitored variables were associated with BMD change. Applications/conclusions Vegetarian women should be aware of links between low BMD and low body weight/body fat, and should maintain adequate intakes of nutrients believed to affect BMD. J Am Diet Assoc. 1998;98:760-765.