Speech therapy after thyroid gland operations in Germany: analysis of routine data from 50,676AOKpatients

Abstract

This study investigated the frequency of postoperative speech therapy in the context of vocal cord palsy after thyroid surgery based on nationwide routine data. Additionally, volume-outcome relationships were examined. Nationwide routine data from insured patients of the Local Health Insurance Fund (AOK) who underwent thyroid surgery for a benign thyroid disease between 2013 and 2015 were analyzed. Postoperative speech therapy was determined based on prescription data. Transient and permanent vocal cord palsy were determined using indicators. The effect of hospital volumes (volume quintiles) on prescription of postoperative speech therapy was determined by multivariate logistic regression. A total of 50,676 thyroid gland operations were identified. The overall frequency of postoperative speech therapy prescription was 6.5%. In AOK patients with transient or permanent vocal cord palsy, the frequencies of postoperative speech therapy prescription were 56.1% and 75.2%, respectively. The prescription volume of the normal case (≥21units of speech therapy) was exceeded in 0.7% of the AOK patients. In the two lowest case volume categories the risk of postoperative speech therapy exceeding the prescription volume of the normal case was significantly higher compared to the highest case volume hospitals (odds ratios: 1.2 and 1.8, respectively). This study presents the reality of healthcare with respect to the frequency of speech therapy prescription after thyroid gland surgery in Germany. In addition, it was determined that the risk of postoperative speech therapy prescription exceeding the volume of the normal case after thyroid gland operations decreases with increasing case volumes of hospitals.