Spectral and Cross-Spectral Analysis of the Long-Swing Hypothesis

Abstract

T HE basic purpose of this paper is to show that an improved understanding of longswing mechanisms in economic-demographic interactions may be attained with cross-spectral analysis even though spectral analysis has, to date, cast only doubt on the existence of such long swings. The superiority of crossspectral analysis to simple estimation of power spectra stems from its emphasis upon examining relationships among economic and other variables (Granger, 1966). For exploration of the long-swing hypothesis, spectral analysis suffers from a further disadvantage its results are sensitive to the form of the data analyzed (levels, rates of growth, or deviations from trend), while cross-spectral analysis is not (see section II). Application of both spectral and cross-spectral analysis to economic and demographic data in Sweden, the United Kingdom, and the United States indicates (1) results of spectral analysis are generally similar across the three countries and negative with respect to the long swing hypothesis; and (2) cross-spectral analysis shows quite different long-swing mechanisms at work while giving some positive confirmation to the Easterlin model of long swings for the United States.