Species-specific growth responses to local and regional climate variability indicate the presence of a diversity portfolio effect in mediterranean tree assemblages

Abstract

Understanding the role of tree biodiversity in stabilizing ecosystem processes is of paramount importance in forest ecology, especially because of increasing temperatures and droughts. The portfolio effect is one of the main hypotheses explaining the biodiversity-stability relationship that has been defined as a variance reduction effect of biodiversity in an ecosystem process, so that fluctuations over time in highly diverse communities become significantly smaller in low-diversity communities. In this work, two main objectives were established: to analyze a potential portfolio effect in a tree assemblage through functional mechanisms of compensation, and to identify the local climatic factors and teleconnections responsible for the interannual variations in the growth of tree species. The study was carried out in a region of the Iberian Peninsula with transitional climatic characteristics that allow the coexistence of needleleaf and broadleaf tree species with a wide variety of strategies and functional traits allowing them to respond differentially to climatic conditions. A dendrochronological approach was followed to analyze tree growth in relation to climate factors. We found that the magnitude and sensitivity of the response to both local climatic elements and teleconnections were species-dependent and that during climatically extreme years, the species exhibited marked differences in tree growth and compensatory responses that contributed to an increase in temporal stability. These results point to the existence of a portfolio effect in Mediterranean woodlands that supports tree diversity as an effective driver of ecosystem stability. Although the combination of dry and hot years always has a negative effect on tree growth, the association of coniferous and broadleaved (evergreen and marcescent) species at our study site could have a significantly positive influence by increasing temporal stability at landscape level through complementary functional responses.