Spawning habitat, behavior, and morphology as isolating mechanisms of the golden redhorse, Moxostoma erythrurum, and the black redhorse, M. duquesnei, two syntopic fishes

Abstract

Golden redhorse, Moxostoma erythrurum, and black redhorse, M. duquesnei, were observed spawning during the springs of 1984 through 1987 in Stony Creek, Illinois, at water temperatures ranging from 15–21°C. Both species spawned simultaneously within the same stream reach in 1987. Male golden redhorse aggressively defended territories on shoals and were joined by females from an adjacent pool. Black redhorse also spawned in riffles and displayed no agonistic behavior. Both species spawned throughout daylight hours in groups of two to five, and golden redhorse also spawned at night. Habitat utilization curves indicate that black redhorse spawned in habitat that was slightly deeper, much swifter, and over coarser substrate than that of the golden redhorse. Males of both species exhibited nuptial body color and breeding tubercles on anal and caudal fins, while only golden redhorse males had head tubercles. We suggest that these differences in spawning habitat, behavior, and morphology act as reproductive isolating mechanisms between the species and that the dichotomy in habitat and behavior may be due to competitive interactions.