Spatial patterns of resource subsidies in Great Lakes tributaries from migratory fishes

Abstract

Migratory fish can influence the stream ecosystems where they spawn by depositing large amounts of energy rich eggs, carcasses, and excrement which can increase primary and secondary productivity. Past research in the Great Lakes has focused on individual tributaries; accordingly, there is a poor understanding of how wide-spread resource subsidies are amongst tributaries. To determine which Great Lake tributaries received subsidies, we compared carbon stable isotope values (δ13C) of resident stream fishes above and below 54 barriers (e.g., low-head lamprey weirs, natural waterfalls) in 31 tributaries. Subsidies, as indicated by the difference in δ13C values above and below barriers, were common. The magnitude of the subsidy varied among Great Lakes with Lake Superior having significantly larger subsidies than the other three lakes. Barrier type (complete, partial) was not related to subsidy magnitude; however, the classification of barrier type was imperfect. Correspondence analysis of regional and local environmental factors showed that large subsidies were associated with oligotrophic streams with steep channels on the Canadian Shield with little agricultural land. The association between subsidies and canopy cover and substrate size were poor. Migratory fish supply resource subsidies to rivers across the Great Lakes basin, though their magnitude is contextually dependent. The presence of barriers are likely limiting the production of migratory fishes that depend on streams for juvenile production. The importance of resource subsidies should be considered when decisions are made about the fate of existing, and the construction of new, barriers that may reduce stream productive capacity.