Spatial and trophic partitioning in cryptic fish communities of shallow subtidal reefs in False Bay, South Africa

Abstract

Thirty-nine species of cryptic fishes belonging to 16 families were captured on shallow reefs (0-20 m) in False Bay, South Africa using the ichthyocide rotenone. Five samples were collected in each of four depth zones (0-5, 6-10, 11-15 and 16-20 m). The area from which fish were collected in each sample was measured to give an estimate of density. The overall density of cryptic fishes in the area was 3.41 fish m-2, with the families Congrogadidae and Clinidae being numerically dominant, representing 27.9% and 22.3% of the total sample respectively. The Clinidae were by far the most diverse group, being represented by 17 species, while no other family was represented by more than three species. Multivariate analysis of numerical density revealed that partitioning of spatial resources did occur, with the shallowest samples (0-5 m) forming a group discrete from the deeper samples (6-20 m). Further analysis indicated that the amount of algal cover present was the most important factor influencing community structure, although the abundance of algae is in turn related to depth. The shallowest samples were dominated by members of the families Clinidae, Gobiesocidae and Bythitidae, while the Cheilodactylidae, Tripterygiidae and Ariidae were more important components of deeper water communities (6–20 m). Analysis of percentage volume of prey items in the diets of 21 species revealed that only two species shared diets that were more than 50% similar, and that partitioning of trophic resources was considerable.