SPARC: A Road Map for Vagus Nerve Stimulation: Evidence of Vagotopy in a Swine Model

Abstract

Cervical vagal nerve stimulation (VNS) is an FDA approved treatment for epilepsy and depression and is currently being evaluated for treatment of numerous other disorders including pain, anxiety, and inflammation. VNS also received European market approval for heart failure, bronchoconstriction, and diabetes; however, approval for these indications was based on studies in animals, such as dogs and rats, whose vagal nerve size may not have been representative of humans. When subjected to double‐blinded, randomized, sham controlled studies for subsequent U.S. approval, many of these CE‐marked VNS indications failed to meet their primary efficacy endpoints. More than 100,000 patients have undergone VNS, but despite the efficacy of vagal nerve stimulation in a subset of patients, many fail to reach stimulation levels that result in alleviation of symptoms without triggering unwanted side effects. Post hoc studies of the patient population suggested that VNS may not engage the intended fiber pathways in humans, despite engagement in preclinical studies in mouse, rat, or dog. Stimulation parameters were limited in these studies as higher parameters caused side effects such as cough, voice alteration, and dyspnea. Discrepancies between stimulation amplitude needed for intended effect versus unwanted side effect could be directly related to the relative size of the vagus nerve across animal models, variations in fascicle organization, or variations in branching patterns.To address translating improvements in VNS from the lab to the clinic, we evaluated the swine as a potential model for approximating the clinical environment. The size and fascicular organization of the swine vagus nerve is more representative of the human nerve than previously used models. We used a combination of histology, microdissection, and ultrasound to establish a distinct bimodal organization of groups of fascicles stemming from one large fascicle at the inferior (nodose) ganglion, an organization we have termed ‘vagotopy’. We demonstrated that with the use of ultrasound we can visualize the fascicular organization in vivo, an approach that could be used clinically to target stimulation of either sensory fibers or parasympathetic efferents, depending on therapeutic intent. These advances in a clinically relevant model not only inform electrode placement for target engagement, but provide an approach for reduction of side effects.Support or Funding InformationAcknowledgementsFunded by TL1TR002380 andThe Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA) Biological Technologies Office (BTO) Targeted Neuroplasticity Training Program under the auspices of Doug Weber and Tristan McClure‐Begley through the Space and Naval Warfare Systems Command (SPAWAR) Systems Center with (SSC) Pacific grants no. N66001‐17‐2‐4010, and the NIH SPARC Program Award OT2 OD025340.