Soil nutrients under shrub hummocks and debris mounds two decades after ploughing

Abstract

Shrub removal by ploughing has been used widely to reduce the effects of shrub encroachment into open woodlands and grasslands. Our aim was to demonstrate that soil chemical properties varied markedly among three patch types (shrub hummock, debris mound, interspace) which varied in age, almost two decades after shrub removal by ploughing. We compared changes in nutrients under 1) young post-ploughing recruits and mature, unploughed shrubs, 2) mature and recently formed debris mounds and 3) ploughed and recovering interspaces at three depths. Irrespective of their age, nutrient concentrations were greater under shrub hummocks and debris mounds than in the interspaces at two sites. Soil in mature shrub hummocks generally had greater levels of labile carbon and nitrogen (total, mineral, mineralisable), but results varied between sites. There were a few, sometimes inconsistent, effects of ploughing on nutrients under debris mounds, and no differences between the interspaces two decades after ploughing. Nutrient effects were most marked in the top 15 cm of the soil, diminishing rapidly with depth. Our results reinforce the importance of hummocks and mounds as resource sinks and indicate the long-lasting effects of disturbances such as ploughing on soil nutrient pools.