Soil nitrogen status 8 years after whole-tree clear-cutting

Abstract

Previous research on chronosequences of even-aged northern hardwood stands has suggested that forest clearing is accompanied by large losses of nitrogen from the forest floor. The timing of the losses and the fate of a large fraction of the lost nitrogen are unclear. The purpose of this investigation was to study these questions through direct measurement of soil nitrogen concentrations and pools through time on an experimental catchment cleared in a whole-tree harvest in 1983–1984. Nitrogen losses from the forest floor at the site, the Hubbard Brook Experimental Forest, New Hampshire, were lower than predictions based on previous research. The mean forest floor nitrogen pool was 17% lower 8 years after clear-cutting of the site (P = 0.18). Predictions based on chronosequence studies suggest that 25–40% of the forest floor nitrogen would be lost after 8 years. Mechanical disturbance during logging may play a role in limiting short-term nitrogen losses. The steep midsection of the catchment experienced the greatest losses of nitrogen and carbon, while pools in the relatively flat spruce-fir zone at the upper elevations were unchanged. Carbon was preferentially lost from soil organic matter, relative to nitrogen, resulting in significant decreases in the C/N and C/organic matter ratios in the soil. The N/organic matter ratio was generally unchanged. Nitrogen losses can be limited after clear-cutting by minimizing organic matter losses and promoting rapid regrowth.