Socioeconomic Status Diversity of Trainees and Faculty in Residency Programs: A Pilot Study in Plastic Surgery

Abstract

The socioeconomic diversity of residents, fellows, and faculty members in any medical or surgical specialty is currently unknown making it difficult to understand socioeconomic status (SES) disparities and create programs to improve diversity. Additionally, the career trajectories of residents and faculty members who come from different SES backgrounds have not been explored. We have performed a survey-based research study to understand the SES composition and career trajectories of residents and faculty members within U.S. Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery (PRS) residency programs. An anonymous online survey was administered to 754 recipients within plastic surgery residency programs in the United States. Self-reported SES information such as household income prior to age 18 and parental education level was collected. Data regarding career trajectories was obtained through questions about away rotations and research productivity. A total of 196 fellows, and faculty members participated in the study, with an estimated survey respondent rate of 25.9%. Only 9.9% (10 of 101) of residents and fellows reported a childhood (under age 18) family income less than $40,000. When analyzing parental education and occupation (EO-status), 42.6% (43 of 101) of residents and fellows had at least 1 parent in an executive, managerial, or professional position with a doctorate/professional degree. Low-income and low EO-status were associated with increased utilization of federal and state assistance programs (p = 0.0001) and approval for AAMC's Fee Assistance Program (FAP) (p = 0.0001). Residents and fellows who identified as White were not as likely to be from low EO-status households as those who identified as Asian (OR 0.3 and p = 0.015 vs. OR 2.9 and p = 0.038). Residents and fellows from low EO-status backgrounds were more likely to take a gap in education (87% vs. 65.4%, p = 0.047) compared to their high EO-status peers. Notably, more current residents and fellows performed away rotations and had first-author publications during or before medical school compared to full professors (p = 0.0001). Understanding the backgrounds and career trajectories of trainees and faculty in medicine is essential, yet it has not been performed at the resident or faculty level. This survey is the first to demonstrate the lack of socioeconomic diversity in a specialty (PRS) and identifies variation in career trajectories among those from different SES backgrounds. Large-scale research efforts are necessary to understand current SES diversity and barriers encountered by trainees and educators from low-SES backgrounds in all medical and surgical specialties.