Sleep Apnea in Maintenance Hemodialysis: A Mixed-Methods Study

Abstract

Rationale & ObjectiveMore than 50% of hemodialysis patients experience sleep disturbance and most have coexisting sleep apnea. However, how sleep apnea affects sleep and the overall experience of patients with chronic kidney disease treated by hemodialysis has not been evaluated.Study DesignA mixed-methods design, incorporating cross-sectional observational and descriptive qualitative methodologies.Setting & ParticipantsPatients receiving maintenance hemodialysis in Newcastle, New South Wales, Australia, with newly diagnosed sleep apnea (apnea-hypopnea index ≥ 5 per hour).AssessmentsIn-laboratory polysomnography to assess sleep apnea and objective sleep parameters. Epworth Sleepiness Scale to assess daytime symptoms. A semi-structured qualitative interview to explore patient experience.Analytical ApproachDescriptive and iterative thematic analysis.ResultsWe analyzed 36 patients with newly diagnosed sleep apnea and interviewed 26 (mean age, 62 years, median apnea-hypopnea index, 32 per hour). Severity of sleep apnea did not affect patients’ sleep duration, sleep efficiency, or self-reported Epworth Sleepiness Scale score. From the qualitative interviews, 4 themes emerged: “broken sleep” related to short sleep duration, with waking and dozing off a common sleep cycle, caused by uncontrolled pain and dialysis. Many participants reported regularly “feeling unrefreshed” on waking. “Impact of sleep disturbance” included reduced physical, mental, and self-management capacity. Finally, interviewees described the need to use strategies to “soldier on” with symptoms.LimitationsParticipants’ views are only transferrable to hemodialysis patients with sleep apnea.ConclusionsOur findings suggest that severity of sleep apnea does not affect sleep time or patient-reported daytime sleepiness; however, hemodialysis patients with sleep apnea report disturbed and unrefreshed sleep and the debilitating effects of sleep disturbance is profound. Broken and unrefreshed sleep were the dominant symptoms of sleep apnea and should be assessed routinely to identify patients with sleep apnea and improve quality of life in patients with chronic kidney disease treated with hemodialysis.