Size Effect in FRP Shear-Strengthened RC Beams: Design Models versus Experimental Data

Abstract

Numerous studies on the size effect have been devoted to reinforced concrete (RC) beams. They have shown that increasing the beam size leads to a decrease in ultimate shear strength (stress) at failure. This is reflected in the design model of most current international codes and guidelines, where the size effect is taken into consideration by reducing concrete contribution to the shear resistance (force). In contrast, the size effect of RC beams strengthened with externally bonded (EB) fibre-reinforced polymer (FRP) is not fully documented, and very few experimental studies have been devoted to the phenomenon. The objective of this study was to evaluate the accuracy of the current code and guideline models in terms of the size effect on the EB-FRP contribution to shear resistance. To this end, a database of experimental findings on the size effect in EB-FRP-strengthened beams was built based on the reported literature, as well as our own experimental tests. The data were analysed and compared with the predictions of six current codes and design guidelines to assess their accuracy. Experimental results clearly revealed the presence of a size effect related to EB-FRP as well as the existence of interaction between internal stirrups and EB-CFRP. Based on analysis of the collected experimental test results, the study clearly revealed that the predictions of current codes and guidelines overestimate the contribution of EB-FRP systems to shear resistance. The size effect tends to exacerbate this overestimation as the effective depth (d) of the beams increases. Therefore, until the size effect for RC beams strengthened in shear with EB-FRP is captured by the prediction models, current codes and design guidelines are to be used with caution.