Singing In The Mask: Effects Of A Variably Occluded Face Mask On Singing

Abstract

A limitation of traditional semi-occluded vocal tract exercises (SOVTE) is the single sustained vowel task that precludes co-articulated singing. This study investigated immediate effects of a variably occluded face mask (VOFM) on vocal effort, acoustic, and aerodynamic measures in sung low and high pitches of healthy singers. Single-group, pre-post intervention study. The outlet ports of disposable anesthesia facemasks were fitted with plastic caps with two drilled openings sizes (9.6 mm, 6.4 mm). Twenty-three singers with no voice complaints provided baseline vocal effort, acoustic, and aerodynamic measures in high and low pitches. Participants trained in four conditions: two VOFM sizes (9.6 mm, 6.4 mm) in combination with the 20th and 80th percentile of the singer's pitch range. Participants were trained on three phonatory tasks: repeated consonant/vowel syllables, sung sentence, and sustained vowel. Vocal effort before and after training was compared using a visual-analog scale, while standardized mean differences captured acoustic and aerodynamic changes before and after training. Participants reported decreased vocal effort after VOFM training at all occlusion and pitch combinations. On average, consistent beneficial effect sizes were found in cepstral peak prominence (CPP) and cepstral spectral index of dysphonia (CSID) for all 4 occlusion-pitch combinations, and vocal intensity and mean estimated subglottal pressure increased for all 4 occlusion-pitch training combinations. Changes in mean phonatory airflow and resistance were less consistent. There was an immediate effect of decreased vocal effort in singing after VOFM training. Acoustic and aerodynamic effects were variable and modest. Future studies should explore changes in these outcomes after VOFM in singing voice therapy.