Simultaneous resistance to multiple anthelmintic classes in nematode parasites of cattle in New Zealand

Abstract

Resistance to the benzimidazole and macrocyclic lactone anthelmintics is widespread in Cooperia spp. on cattle farms in New Zealand. Since this was first documented in 2006 little has changed in cattle farming systems except for the widespread use of levamisole to control Cooperia spp. in young cattle (i.e., parasite control has maintained an almost total reliance on use of anthelmintics). Here we report the emergence of simultaneous resistance to the benzimidazole, macrocyclic lactone and levamisole anthelmintics in Cooperia spp. and in Ostertagia spp. Anthelmintic efficacy against nematode parasites of cattle was investigated on four commercial farms following reports of poor animal growth rates and welfare, and positive faecal egg counts, despite routine treatment with combination anthelmintics, which included levamisole. Faecal egg count reduction tests involved 15 animals per treatment group, individual egg counts (paired samples) conducted pre- and post-treatment, with eggs counted to ≤ 15 eggs per g faeces and larval cultures for morphological identification. Actives tested varied between farms but always included levamisole alone and several combination products containing levamisole. Of the 20 tests conducted (i.e., 5 products on each of 4 farms) only 3 exceeded 90% efficacy against Cooperia spp. even though 8 of the products tested were combinations containing levamisole and at least one other broad-spectrum anthelmintic. Levamisole used alone achieved efficacies between 44% and 71% against Cooperia spp. across the four trials. The only product to exceed 95% efficacy against Cooperia spp. was a combination of monepantel + abamectin which was 100% effective against all parasites. Resistance to oxfendazole in Ostertagia spp. was indicated on 3 farms, while on one farm efficacy of all the tested products was ≤75% against this parasite. All the farms involved in this study were farming intensive cattle operations with an almost total reliance on anthelmintics to control parasitism. The results clearly demonstrate the emergence of simultaneous resistance to oxfendazole, levamisole and the macrocyclic lactone anthelmintics. Despite years of advice and recommendations to change farming practices away from intensive monocultures, many farmers have continued with the practice, and some are now faced with the very real possibility of being unable to control cattle parasites on their farms.