Simulation-Based Education in US Undergraduate Medical Education: A Descriptive Study.

Abstract

Simulation-based education (SBE) provides experiential learning, improvement in quality of care, and reduction in errors. In 2011, the Association of American Medical Colleges described adoption of SBE in 68.0% of medical schools and 25.0% of teaching hospitals. We sought to examine current trends of SBE integration in American undergraduate medical education since previous publications. From 2016 to 2019, University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center postgraduate year 1 residents were invited to participate in a survey assessing medical school simulation experience with 26 clinical tasks from three categories: procedural, communication, and other. Deidentified results were analyzed to assess demographics including sex, specialty, residency program type, allopathic versus osteopathic medical school, and medical school region. Nine hundred sixty-seven of 1047 (92.3%) responses were obtained, representing 139 US medical schools, 91% from allopathic training. Of procedural tasks, most simulated was suturing (n = 848, 89.6%) and least simulated was thoracentesis (n = 737, 80.9%). Of communication tasks, most simulated was taking a history (n = 475, 51.1% reporting simulation >30) and least simulated (never or ≤1) were obtaining a consent (n = 669, 73.2%) and disclosing a medical error (n = 666, 72.4%). Of other tasks, most simulated was chest compressions (n = 898, 96.0%) and least simulated was operating a defibrillator (n = 206, 22.1%). Results were similar regardless of procedural or nonprocedural program. There was no significant difference in SBE exposure between allopathic and osteopathic students ( P = 0.89). Two participants (0.002%) reported no simulation exposure. Our study is the first to describe a high prevalence of SBE adoption in medical schools nationwide since the Association of American Medical Colleges' 2011 publication, with overall equal exposure for students regardless of residency type and allopathic or osteopathic medical school. Despite widespread adoption of simulation, opportunities remain to expand SBE use to teach critically important communication skills.