Simulation and experimental benchmarking of a proton pencil beam scanning nozzle model for development of MR-integrated proton therapy.

Abstract

MR-integrated proton therapy is under development. It consists of the unique challenge of integrating a proton pencil beam scanning (PBS) beam line nozzle with an magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scanner. The magnetic interaction between these two components is deemed high risk as the MR images can be degraded if there is cross-talk during beam delivery and imageacquisition. To create and benchmark a self-consistent proton PBS nozzle model for empowering the next stages of MR-integrated proton therapy development, namely exploring and de-risking complete integrated prototype system designs including magnetic shielding of the PBS nozzle. Magnetic field (COMSOL ) and radiation transport (Geant4) models of a proton PBS nozzle located at OncoRay (Dresden, Germany) were developed according to the manufacturers specifications. Geant4 simulations of the PBS process were performed by using magnetic field data generated by the COMSOL simulations. In total 315 spots were simulated which consisted of a scan pattern with 5cm spot spacings and for proton energies of 70, 100, 150, 200, and 220MeV. Analysis of the simulated deflection at the beam isocenter plane was performed to determine the self-consistency of the model. The magnetic fringe field from a sub selection of 24 of the 315 spot simulations were directly compared with high precision magnetometer measurements. These focused on the maximum scanning setting of 20cm beam deflection as generated from the second scanning magnet in the PBS for a proton beam energy of 220MeV. Locations along the beam line central axis (CAX) were measured at beam isocenter and downstream of 22, 47, 72, 97, and 122cm. Horizontal off-axis positions were measured at 22cm downstream of isocenter ( 50, 100, and 150cm from CAX). The proton PBS simulations had good spatial agreement to the theoretical values in all 315 spots examined at the beam line isocenter plane (0-2.9mm differences or within 1.5% of the local spot deflection amount). Careful analysis of the experimental measurements were able to isolate the changes in magnetic fields due solely to the scanning magnet contribution, and showed 1.9 1.2 -9.4 1.2 changes over the range of measurement locations. Direct comparison with the equivalent simulations matched within the measurement apparatus and setup uncertainty in all but one measurementpoint. For the first time a robust, accurate and self-consistent model of a proton PBS nozzle assembly has been created and successfully benchmarked for the purposes of advancing MR-integrated proton therapy research. The model will enable confidence in further simulation based work on fully integrated designs including MRI scanners and PBS nozzle magnetic shielding in order to de-risk and realize the full potential of MR-integrated proton therapy.