Simplified, ideal or inverted decoupling?

Abstract

This paper presents a comparative study of simplified, ideal and inverted decoupling. The stability, robustness and implementation of the three decoupling methods are studied. The structured singular value (SSV) is used to carry out some comparisons. It is demonstrated that robust performance and robust stability of a nominally stable control system are equivalent for the three decoupling methods when the controllers are tuned to obtain identical nominal performance. A relation is derived between the presence of right-half plane (RHP) zeros of a process in series with its simplified decoupler and the instability of the ideal and inverted decouplers for the same process. This paper also describes a potential implementation problem related to the particular structure of the inverted decoupling. Finally, a recapitulative table of the main advantages and limitations of each decoupling method is presented.