Should we operate?: The role of surgery in HER2+ de novo metastatic breast cancer treated with dual anti-HER2+ blockade

Abstract

Abstract Title: Does definitive local therapy have a role in select HER2+de novo metastatic breast cancer patients treated with dual anti HER2 blockade? Background: The role of surgery with curative intent in HER2+de novo metastatic breast cancer (dnMBC) is uncertain in the era of dual antibody therapy. We sought to determine from existing retrospective data current practice patterns if an association exists between surgery to the primary tumor and improved survival in HER2+dnMBC patients treated with dual anti-HER2 blockade, accounting for selection bias. Methods: This study employed data from the National Cancer Database (NCDB) from the years 2013 to 2015. Study inclusion was limited to adult women with HER2+dnMBC, who received immunotherapy/biologic response modifier drugs (BRM) as a first line treatment. Patients who received both systemic therapy and surgery to the primary breast tumor and patients who received systemic therapy alone were analyzed in two groups. Chi-square test for discrete variables and Wilcox on RankSum test for numeric variables was used to compare the two groups based on patient, tumor, and treatment characteristics. The primary endpoint was overall survival from the time of diagnosis to the time of death. Results: 928 women with HER2+dnMBC treated with BRM were identified with 43.5% (n=404) receiving surgery and 56.5% (n=524) receiving systemic therapy alone. The 3-year overall survival was superior for the surgery group (74.1%, 95% CI 67.9–79.2%) compared to the no surgery group (53.3%; 95% CI 47.6–58.6%). The no surgery group had median overall survival of 39.8 months (95% CI 34.1–44.9), while the surgery group had not yet reached median overall survival. Conclusion: In a group of HER2+dnMBC patients receiving systemic treatment in the era of dual antibody therapy, patients who underwent surgery had a superior 3-year survival rate than those who did not. There may be a role for a prospective trial in HER2+dnMBC patients with an excellent response to dual HER2 blockade to investigate the contribution of curative intent local therapy to the primary tumor compared to systemic therapy alone.