Short-Term Changes in Prediction Error after Cataract Surgery in Eyes Receiving 1 of 3 Types of Single-Piece Acrylic Intraocular Lenses

Abstract

To compare short-term changes in refractive prediction error (PE) after phacoemulsification among eyes receiving different types of single-piece acrylic intraocular lenses (IOLs). Randomized clinical trial. A total of 195 eyes of 195 patients scheduled for implantation of a single-piece acrylic IOL were randomly assigned to receive 1 of 3 IOLs: 1) an Alcon model SN60WF, 2) a Hoya model XY-1, or 3) an AMO model ZCB00V. Manifest spherical equivalent (MRSE) value, PE, and changes in PE were examined at 1day and at 1 and 2months postoperatively and were compared among groups. The mean MRSE and PE significantly changed toward myopia between 1day and 2months postoperatively in all groups (P < .0001). The MRSE and PE did not differ significantly among groups at 1day and 1month postoperatively and were significantly smaller in the SN60WF group than in the XY-1 and ZCB00V groups at 2months (P ≤ .0006). The PE change between 1day and 2months postoperatively was significantly smaller in the SN60WF group than in the other groups (P= .0062). IOL type and changes in anterior chamber depth and corneal curvature independently correlated with PE changes. The MRSE and PE showed a significant myopic change for 2months postoperatively in eyes implanted with 1 of 3 types of single-piece acrylic IOLs and were significantly smaller in the SN60WF than in the XY-1 and ZCB00V groups. Changes in PE during the 2 postoperative months were smaller in the SN60WF IOLs than in the other IOLs, suggesting that postoperative refractive stability differs among single-piece acrylic IOLs.