Short-term effects of retention forestry on the diversity of root-associated ectomycorrhizal fungi in Sakhalin fir plantations, Hokkaido, Japan

Abstract

We have examined the effects of dispersed and aggregated retention on the diversity of root-associated ectomycorrhizal fungi (EcMf) in Sakhalin fir (Abies sachalinensis) plantations, 4 years after logging. Roots of Sakhalin fir seedlings and the adjacent broadleaved or Sakhalin fir trees were sampled in broadleaved dispersed retention sites (10, 50, or 100 trees/ha), conifer aggregated retention sites (a single 60 × 60 m square patch of Sakhalin fir trees per site), clear-cut sites, unharvested Sakhalin fir plantations, and natural broadleaved forest stands. The EcMf on the roots were grouped into operational taxonomic units based on the similarity of the internal transcribed spacer sequences within the nuclear ribosomal DNA. Clear-cutting significantly reduced the species richness and diversity of the EcMf and altered the species composition when compared with the unharvested Sakhalin fir plantations and natural broadleaved forests. In contrast, both the aggregated and dispersed retention sites maintained higher levels of EcMf diversity, as well as different EcMf communities when compared with the clear-cut sites. Aggregated retention was effective at conserving EcMf diversity at the unharvested Sakhalin fir plantations, but the effects were limited within retained patches. Broadleaved dispersed retention did not retain the EcMf communities that were present prior to logging even at high retention levels, but they could retain unique EcMf communities, which differed between the Sakhalin fir plantations, natural broadleaved forests, and clear-cut sites. The species richness and diversity values for some of the dispersed retention sites were comparable to the values for the unharvested Sakhalin fir plantations and tended to be greater than the values for the aggregated retention sites. The results indicate that dispersed retention could be an effective strategy by which to preserve a larger number of EcMf species and unique EcMf communities in logged conifer plantations, although the positive effects were likely limited spatially within the rooting zones of the retained broadleaved trees. Finally, naturally regenerating Sakhalin fir seedlings were found to share a large amount of their EcMf with adjacent broadleaved retention trees, indicating that multi-host EcMf of retained trees largely contribute to ectomycorrhizal colonization of the surrounding regenerated seedlings in the logged areas. Our findings demonstrated that both dispersed and aggregated retention methods could be used to mitigate the impacts of logging on EcMf diversity in Sakhalin fir plantations, in Japan, and that there were large differences in the effects among the different retention methods.