Short-term effect of thinning on the carbon budget of young and middle-aged silver birch (Betula pendula Roth) stands

Abstract

Although thinning is a widely used silvicultural method, its effect on stand carbon (C) cycling is still poorly studied at the ecosystem level. The present case study estimated the two-year post-thinning effect on the C balance of a pole and a middle-aged silver birch stand. The results demonstrate the multifaceted impact of thinning on the different C fluxes of deciduous forest ecosystems.The effect of thinning on the C budget of the studied stands was modest: net ecosystem production (NEP) decreased by 1.2 and 1.6 t C ha−1 yr−1 in the pole and the middle- aged stand, respectively; still, both stands remained C sinks. Lower annual production in the thinned stands as a result of the decreased standing biomass of the trees was the main factor for reduced C sequestration capacity. Thinning increased the C accumulation of the herbaceous plants in both stands, however, it did not compensate for the lower C accumulation by the trees. In general, thinning did not affect significantly the soil respiration fluxes; the small post-thinning increase of the annual soil heterotrophic flux, 0.33–0.68 t C ha −1, was most probably related to elevated soil temperature during the active growing season. The annual aboveground litter flux, i.e. the labile C source of Rh, was not significantly changed by thinning. Fine root production and the belowground C input to the soil remained at the same level in the pole stand and decreased slightly in the middle-aged stand. We conclude that the high production ability and fast C accumulation recovery of silver birch stands growing on fertile soils leads to a balanced C budget already during the short post-thinning period.