Short communication: Comparison of 3 rapid methods for analysis of vitamin degradation compounds in fluid skim milk

Abstract

Vitamin fortification of dairy products, including fluid milk and fortified whey protein beverages, is an industry standard but can lead to the development of off-flavor compounds that are difficult to extract and detect by instrumental methods. Previous work has identified these compounds and their specific role in off-flavors in skim milk, but efficient extraction and quantification of these compounds remains a challenge. Three rapid methods (stir bar sorptive extraction, solvent-assisted stir bar sorptive extraction, and solid-phase microextraction) were compared for their ability to effectively recover vitamin degradation volatiles from fluid skim milk. The performance of the 3 methods for detecting and quantifying vitamin degradation-related volatile compounds was determined by linear regression of standard curves prepared from spiked standards of 5 vitamin degradation volatiles, the reproducibility on the same day and between days as measured by the average relative standard deviation of each standard curve, and the limits of detection and quantitation. Measurement of vitamin degradation compounds in commercial pasteurized fortified skim milks was also conducted using each method. Detection of selected vitamin degradation volatiles was linear in skim milk (0.005-200 μg/kg). Coefficient of determination values differed between methods and compounds. Within-day and between-day percentage of relative standard deviation also varied with compound and method. Limits of detection and quantitation values for all methods except solid-phase microextraction were lower than concentrations of selected volatile compounds typically found in commercial milk. Solvent-assisted stir bar sorptive extraction with a 10-mL sample volume provided the most consistent detection of selected compounds in commercial milks. Based on linearity, relative standard deviation, and limits of detection and quantitation, cyclohexane solvent-assisted stir bar sorptive extraction with 10-mL sample volume is recommended for the quantitation of vitamin degradation-related volatiles in fluid skim milk.