Shift in limiting nutrients in the late Ediacaran–early Cambrian marine systems of South China

Abstract

The Ediacaran to Cambrian periods are characterized by the diversification and extinction of metazoans, carbon-cycle perturbation, and ocean oxygenation. Ocean nutrient cycles play a major role in the primary production and productivity-driven shallow water anoxia that was responsible for mass extinction in some Phanerozoic intervals. However, the relationships between these cycles and primary production and biological events during the Ediacaran to Cambrian periods have not previously been well-explored. This study presents stratigraphic profiles of nitrogen and organic carbon isotopes for sections belonging to the shelf and deep basin regions of the Yangtze Platform, South China. The nitrogen isotope profiles for these two regions share a similar trend, showing 1) relatively stable δ15N values of 5–6‰ in the early–middle Ediacaran (635 Ma–ca. 560 Ma) and 2) a shift towards lower δ15N values (3–4‰) since the Shuram δ13Ccarb Excursion. The δ15N values in the shelf section experienced a two-stage decrease from the late Ediacaran to Cambrian Stage 2 of the Terreneuvian series (down to −1‰) and then an increase from −1‰ to +4‰ across the Cambrian Stage 2/3 boundary (i.e., the Terreneuvian/Cambrian Series 2 boundary at 521 Ma). These data, in combination with previously reported nutrient profiles (δ15N, P, and Mo), allow the following new conclusions to be drawn. 1) The early–middle Ediacaran ocean was characterized by NMo colimitation of primary production on a geological timescale that is different from the P limitation on long-term primary production in the modern ocean. 2) A shift in the ultimate limiting nutrient from N and Mo to P likely occurred in late Ediacaran–early Cambrian marine systems. This shift may have been a prerequisite for the extinction of small shelly fossils in response to the development of photic zone anoxia for several million years in Cambrian Stage 2, which was followed by the third and most prominent phase of metazoan diversification.