ShatterPlots: Fast Tools for Mining Large Graphs

Abstract

Graphs appear in several settings, like social networks, recommendation systems, computer communication networks, gene/protein biological networks, among others. A deep, recurring question is “What do real graphs look like?” That is, how can we separate real ones from synthetic or real graphs with masked portions? The main contribution of this paper is ShatterPlots, a simple and powerful algorithm to extract patterns from real graphs that help us spot fake/masked graphs. The idea is to shatter a graph, by deleting edges, force it to reach a critical (“Shattering”) point, and study the properties at that point. One of the most striking patterns is the “30-per-cent”: at the Shattering point, all real and synthetic graphs have about 30% more nodes than edges. One of our most discriminative patterns is the “NodeShatteringRatio ”, which can almost perfectly separate the real graphs from the synthetic ones of our extensive collection. Additional contributions of this paper are (a) the careful, scalable design of the algorithm, which requires only O(E) time, (b) extensive experiments in a large collection of graphs (19 in total), with up to hundreds of thousands of nodes and million edges, and (c) a wealth of observations and patterns, which show how to distinguish synthetic or masked graphs from real ones.