Sex, secondary compounds and asymmetry. Effects on plant–herbivore interaction in a dioecious shrub

Abstract

We analysed the links between herbivory, anthraquinone content and developmental instability of leaves in Rhamnus alpinus , taking into account possible effects of sexual dimorphism. The amount of leaf loss caused by herbivores averaged 3%, rarely exceeding 25%. Leaf losses were evenly distributed in the shrubs, with highest variability among leaves of the same shoot, thus hiding possible shrub, sex or population effects. This pattern of herbivory implies a shifting of caterpillars from one leaf to another before consuming all readily available material. We suggest that this behaviour might be triggered by a short-term change in leaf palatability by means of an increase in the production of secondary compounds. Supporting this hypothesis, we have found a higher anthraquinone content in damaged leaves compared with undamaged ones. The leaves of male plants exhibited a higher concentration of anthraquinones than those of females, which contrasts with classic hypotheses. We relate this to the lower rate of biomass increase in males, which should allow them to allocate more resources to defence. Leaves showed fluctuating asymmetry (FA), but we did not find any relationship between the degree of asymmetry and sex, herbivory or anthraquinone content at any level considered. Therefore, FA cannot be considered as an indicator of susceptibility to damage by herbivores or of the ability to induce the production of defensive compounds in R. alpinus .