Severity Classification of Clinical Signs and Defining the Moribund State as an Experimental Endpoint for Acute Toxicity Testing Using Japanese Medaka (Oryzias latipes).

Abstract

Use of the moribund state as an endpoint for acute toxicity testing in fish is complicated by the lack of consensus about the sublethal signs that define the state or that can predict imminent death. Defining the moribund state in fish requires determination of the association between each observable sublethal sign and transition to imminent death. To establish a criterion for defining the moribund state in Japanese medaka (Oryzias latipes), we determined death/clinical-sign ratios, defined as the proportion of fish with each clinical sign that transitioned to imminent death, for 13 clinical signs observed in individually housed fish exposed to one of two typical toxicants, three pharmaceuticals, two pesticides, and one metal. Also, the time from onset of each clinical sign to transition to imminent death (referred to as the survival time) was determined by continuous monitoring. Three of the observed clinical signs-immobility, lethargy, and immobility at the surface-were found to be indicators of the moribund state, with each of these signs having a death/clinical-sign ratio of 1.0. Evaluation of the survival time after onset of the other 10 signs enabled determination of whether timely euthanasia would be appropriate, thereby providing a means of reducing the suffering of laboratory fish in the period before death. Environ Toxicol Chem 2022;41:1089-1095. © 2022 SETAC.