Selective Grazing of Hairless Silene dioica Plants by Land Gastropods

Abstract

Silene dioica (Caryophyllaceae) has evolved different morphotypes that vary in hairiness in different habitats in the Swedish mountains. A hairy form, var. serpentinicola and a hairless (glabrous) form, var. smithii grow on serpentine, i.e. a dry soil rich in heavy metals. Var. lapponica is a densely hairy morphotype on subalpine meadows. Crosses between these varieties showed that glabrousness has a simple Mendelian inheritance and that glabrousness is determined by a recessive allele. The crosses further suggested that the recessive allele has been present in the original population that invaded the mountain area. Glabrous plants have, however, never been found on subalpine meadows, even though an earlier study has shown that gene flow is relatively common among serpentine and nearby meadow populations. In addition to the genetic background of glabrousness, we studied the grazing on glabrous smithii and hairy serpentinicola and lapponica plants by the slugs Arion fasciatus and Arion subfuscus and the snail Arianta arbustorum in greenhouse and in nature. Arion slugs, abundant on subalpine meadows, preferred glabrous plants and, in particular, A. fasciatus consumed high amounts of S. dioica. Arianta snails, however, consumed irrespective of morphotype. The selective behaviour was seen both at the seedling stage and the adult plant stage. Arion slugs were more choosy when they were given a choice of glabrous smithii and densely hairy lapponica plants then when they were served smithii and the less hairy variety serpentinicola. This study implies that the Arion slugs are important agents of selection on subalpine meadows. The selective grazing seems to counteract the flow of the recessive allele that determines glabrousness, from serpentine into meadow populations. Gastropods are rare in the dry serpentine habitat. The evolution of a distinct glabrous morphotype on serpentine is therefore rather due to relaxation of selection than to adaptation to serpentine stress.