Secondary caries-like lesions at fissure sealings with Xeno III and Delton—an in vitro study

Abstract

The aim of the study was to establish a bacterial based in vitro caries model to test the caries preventive effect of fissure sealants and to investigate whether a self-etching adhesive (Xeno III) used as fissure sealant is equally effective in preventing secondary caries compared to a conventional sealant (Delton) when applied on saliva contaminated and non-contaminated fissures. Forty caries-free upper premolars were randomly divided into two groups. Group A was sealed with a conventional resin-based fissure sealant (Delton) after phosphoric acid etching. Group B was sealed with a self-etching adhesive (Xeno III) without prior etching. To simulate the clinical situation of saliva contamination, the distal part of each tooth was slightly moistened with saliva before sealant application. After thermo-cycling, the specimens were exposed to a cariogenic Streptococcus mutans biofilm in an artificial mouth model. Depths of demineralization were measured on serial sections by confocal laser scanning microscopy. If a demineralization was detected underneath the whole fissure sealing the sample was rated as 'total failure'. Significantly higher numbers of total failures could be found in the Xeno III group compared to the Delton group in areas without saliva contamination. On contaminated areas, no significant difference could be found. There was no significant difference regarding the depth of the primary carious lesions between groups. The study supports our recent findings that our caries model is capable to produce secondary caries-like lesions at fissure sealings. Based on the present in vitro data, it cannot be recommended to use the self-etching adhesive Xeno III solely as a fissure sealant.