Seasonal and age-related variation in the needle quality of five conifer species.

Abstract

Age changes of foliage resource quality (water, nitrogen, fibre, phenolics and toughness) were studied in five species of conifer (Pinus sylvestris L.), Picea abies (L.) Karsten, Tsuga heterophylla (Rafinesque) Sargent (all Pinaceae), Chamaecyparis lawsonian (Murray) Parlatore and Thuja plicata D. Don (both Cupressaceae) over a 2-year period in an English forest.Mature foliage of Pinus sylvestris was characterized by higher levels of nitrogen, fibre and toughness, and lower phenolics, and that of Tsuga heterophylla by higher levels of phenolics, and lower fibre and toughness levels, than the mature needles of the other species studied. Immature needles had higher levels of water and nitrogen, and lower levels of fibre and toughness, than older needles. Immature needles of Picea abies and Tsuga heterophylla had a high concentration of phenolics, which decreased with needle maturity. By mid-August, the levels of most of the foliar constituents in current-year needles had stabilized at levels maintained for the next year. Sampling revealed a fall in the concentration of phenolics, fibre and water in mature needles between March and June. Possible reasons for this seasonal trend are discussed. The levels of conifer foliar constituents were compared with levels recorded in broadleaf trees. Conifers had greater concentrations of all measured foliar constituents, but, with the exception of the six fold greater toughness of conifer needles, the differences between broadleaves and conifers were less than those between the immature and mature conifer needles. Previous studies have related the abundance of Lepidoptera on conifers to hostplant taxonomic relationships. However, the foliar constituents measured in this study were poor predictors of taxonomic relationships between the conifers. It is suggested that the abundance of Lepidoptera on conifers is not determined by levels of general foliar constituents and the role of other hostplant factors in shaping lepidopteran utilization of conifers is discussed.