Sea vs. Bay Water Desalination: Which One is for You?

  • Abstract
  • Literature Map
  • Similar Papers
Abstract
Translate article icon Translate Article Star icon
Take notes icon Take Notes

Both brackish water desalination and seawater desalination processes are well established and in common use around the globe to create new water supply sources. The farther the location of the source water from the ocean or seashore, the lower the salinity (TDS) of the water and the lower the osmotic pressure that needs to be overcome when desalinated water is produced. This is one of the major reasons that brackish desalination is often considered less costly than seawater desalination. A number of project considerations, however, indicate that seawater desalination can be beneficial and more cost-effective than brackish water desalination. To make a fair comparison, we need to properly compare all major aspects of both types of projects to define the best and most appropriate desalination technology. While brackish water has less feed water TDS, it is more challenging to dispose of the produced concentrate. Also, although brackish water desalination needs less energy to overcome osmotic pressure, it usually requires more energy to draw the water from the well than it takes to pump seawater from the open ocean intake. Another factor is that the temperature of the brackish well water may be lower than the temperature of ocean water, giving seawater desalination an advantage in energy demand. In comparing brackish to seawater desalination, these major aspects should be evaluated: (1) Locations of seawater and brackish water plants, relative to the major consumers of the desalinated water, (2) Transportation (pumping and disposal) costs of the feed water and produced water, (3) Potential colocation of a seawater plant with a large industrial user (e.g., power plant) of the seawater for cooling or other purposes, (4) Produced quality of brackish water and seawater desalination in terms of major minerals and emerging contaminants, (5) Sustainability of the water source: capacity and depth of the brackish water wells, as well as the type of soil. (6) Technical and economic aspects of produced concentrate disposal, (7) Permitting process costs for brackish and seawater desalination, and (8) The economics of both brackish and seawater desalination treatment processes: capital costs, operational and maintenance (O&M) costs, lifetime water cost, and total water cost (TWC). This paper discusses the major evaluation criteria and considerations involved in properly comparing the economic and technical aspects of brackish and seawater desalination to determine the more favorable desalination technology for a given desalination project.

Similar Papers
  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 18
  • 10.1016/s0011-9164(02)00934-7
The role of desalination in bridging the water gap in Jordan
  • Oct 1, 2002
  • Desalination
  • H.A.Abu Qdais + 1 more

The role of desalination in bridging the water gap in Jordan

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 84
  • 10.1021/acs.est.9b04436
Integrated Flow-Electrode Capacitive Deionization and Microfiltration System for Continuous and Energy-Efficient Brackish Water Desalination.
  • Oct 28, 2019
  • Environmental Science & Technology
  • Changyong Zhang + 5 more

Flow-electrode capacitive deionization (FCDI) is an emerging electrochemically driven technology for brackish and/or sea water desalination with merits of large salt adsorption capacity, high flow efficiency, and easy electrode management. While FCDI holds promise for continuous operation, there are very few investigations with regard to the regeneration/reuse of flowable electrodes and the separation of brine from electrodes with these operation prerequisites for real nonintermittent water desalination. In this study, we propose a novel module design to achieve these critical steps involving integration of an FCDI cell and a ceramic microfiltration (MF) contactor. Our investigations reveal that the brine discharge rate is the dominant factor for stable and efficient operation of the integrated module. Results obtained show that the integrated FCDI/MF system can be used to successfully separate brackish water (of salinities 1, 2 and 5 g L-1) into both a potable stream (<0.5 g L-1) and a brine stream (concentrated by 2-20 times) in a continuous manner with extremely high water recovery rates (up to 97%) and reasonable energy consumption. Another notable characteristic of the integrated system is the high thermodynamic energy efficiency (∼30%) with such efficiencies 4-5 times larger than those of conventional capacitive deionization units and comparable to reverse osmosis and electrodialysis systems achieving similar separation efficiencies. In brief, the results of studies described here indicate that continuous and efficient operation of FCDI is a real possibility and pave the way for scale-up of this emerging technology.

  • Research Article
  • 10.1016/0011-9164(85)80098-9
Analysis of desalination alternates for phosphoric acid plant in Tunisia
  • Jan 1, 1985
  • Desalination
  • C.D Hornburg

Analysis of desalination alternates for phosphoric acid plant in Tunisia

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 31
  • 10.1016/s0011-9164(01)00193-x
A methodology to investigate brackish groundwater desalination coupled with aquifer recharge by treated wastewater as an alternative strategy for water supply in Mediterranean areas
  • May 1, 2001
  • Desalination
  • Elena Georgopoulou + 5 more

A methodology to investigate brackish groundwater desalination coupled with aquifer recharge by treated wastewater as an alternative strategy for water supply in Mediterranean areas

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 75
  • 10.1016/j.desal.2020.114445
Desalination of high salinity brackish water by an NF-RO hybrid system
  • Jun 26, 2020
  • Desalination
  • Jennifer Runhong Du + 5 more

Desalination of high salinity brackish water by an NF-RO hybrid system

  • Conference Article
  • 10.1117/12.2638652
Performance enhancement of membrane distillation in the desalina-tion of sea water and brackish water
  • Apr 29, 2022
  • Chao Liu + 6 more

In order to meet people's increasing demand for water, it is urgent to transform undrinkable water resources such as seawater and brackish water into water suitable for human use. Membrane distillation has become a water treatment technology with great development potential due to its advantages of high desalination rate, good water quality, high water recovery and low operating cost. It can effectively solve the problem of desalination of seawater and brackish water, and has broad application prospects in solving the shortage of fresh water resources. However, membrane fouling and polarization effect limit the performance of membrane distillation in seawater desalination. This paper briefly describes the working principle of membrane distillation technology, analyzes the formation mechanism of polarization effect and membrane fouling, and introduces the technical methods for enhancing the performance of membrane distillation. In addition, the future research direction of membrane distillation is prospected.

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 182
  • 10.1016/j.watres.2020.116064
Brackish water desalination using reverse osmosis and capacitive deionization at the water-energy nexus
  • Jun 18, 2020
  • Water Research
  • Shu-Yuan Pan + 3 more

Brackish water desalination using reverse osmosis and capacitive deionization at the water-energy nexus

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 97
  • 10.1016/j.desal.2015.02.010
Desalination and disinfection of inland brackish ground water in a capacitive deionization cell using nanoporous activated carbon cloth electrodes
  • Feb 16, 2015
  • Desalination
  • Karthik Laxman + 5 more

Desalination and disinfection of inland brackish ground water in a capacitive deionization cell using nanoporous activated carbon cloth electrodes

  • Research Article
  • 10.1111/j.1745-6584.2007.00376_2.x
Authors’ Reply
  • Oct 26, 2007
  • Groundwater
  • E Weinthal + 4 more

A<scp>uthors</scp>’ R<scp>eply</scp>

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 15
  • 10.1016/s0011-9164(03)00330-8
Impact of chemical composition of reject brine from inland desalination plants on soil and groundwater, UAE
  • Aug 1, 2003
  • Desalination
  • Juma K Al-Handhaly + 2 more

Impact of chemical composition of reject brine from inland desalination plants on soil and groundwater, UAE

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 7
  • 10.2166/aqua.2018.094
Desalination of brackish water for agriculture: challenges and future perspectives for seawater intrusion areas in Vietnam
  • Feb 21, 2018
  • Journal of Water Supply: Research and Technology-Aqua
  • Vo Huu Cong

This research aims to provide an overview of the seawater encroachment threat on agriculture in lowland areas and potential solutions for better practices. It was found that the Mekong river delta experiences severe impacts from climate change with more than 75% of provinces affected by seawater intrusion, of which Kien Giang, Ca Mau and Ben Tre provinces are the most influenced with 70% affected areas. The salinity of river water was observed in the range of 15–30 g/L in 2015; meanwhile, the strongest tolerated rice species reached ceiling values of 3–4 g/L. Emerging challenges were identified due to the uncertain upstream hydrological regime coupled with high levels of tide, field evaporation and water withdrawal. The development strategies of affected provinces are given on the modification of rice tolerant capacity, and modification to aquaculture in areas with high salinity, in which water purification is in urgent demand. Desalination technologies have been proposed with various innovations which are still not practical on a large scale. The desalination of seawater and brackish water by reverse osmosis, nano-filtration, electro-dialysis, ion-exchange resins, electrochemical processes and thermal distillation has been applied to agriculture. The advance reverse osmosis shows most potential because of its advances in treating performance, cost effectiveness and effective rejection of brine.

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 4
  • 10.1088/1757-899x/926/1/012011
Porous Graphene for Sea Water Desalination Considering the Effects of Fluorine/nitrogen Modification: A Molecular Dynamic Study
  • Sep 1, 2020
  • IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering
  • Zhang Fa

Sea water desalination becomes more and more important as the consumption of fresh water. Forward osmosis (FO) is a novel technology for sea water or brackish water desalination, where a most important device, semi-permeable membrane, are required low resistance, high selection and inexpensive. In this study, based on molecular dynamic simulations, we explored the performance of porous graphene as the semi-permeable membrane for sea water desalination. Fluorine (F) and nitrogen (N) are adopted to optimize the property of graphene pore. We found that although pure pore have highest water flux (indicating lower resistance), N modified pore has the best selection due to the high electronegativity of N atoms. The about 60 L/cm2/h water flux and 100% solute rejection ratio confirm the graphene with N modified pores is good candidate as a semi-permeable membrane for sea water desalination.

  • Dissertation
  • 10.24377/ljmu.t.00008585
Desalination technologies and environmental aspects : case study in Libya
  • Apr 11, 2018
  • A Elhajaji

Water, otherwise known as the pool of life, is the very essence of all living things and as such is vital for survival, whether for living beings, social, economic development or for environmental sustainability. However, its continuing existence is severely threatened for future as a result of climate change, carbon footprint, population growth, environmental damage, combined with natural disasters like droughts and floods. The prospect of an alternative solution such as desalination of sea or brackish water to counter the limit on conventional water resources such as groundwater, which cannot meet demand, is therefore very promising, particularly in arid and semi-arid regions where water scarcity and impaired quality prevails. Consequently, desalination technology has now become a burgeoning industry in North Africa or southern Mediterranean countries, such as in Libya. However, evidence suggests that as a result of by-products being discharged directly into the sea, particularly from coastal desalination plants, the physico-chemical parameters of the receiving water are changing and posing a threat to marine ecosystems. As a result of studies conducted on these parameters to analyse the brine emitted from the Zwuarah and the West Tripoli distillation plants (ZWDP & WTRIS) on the Libyan coastline, evidence shows there is a significant positive correlation at both sites between the biological data and physico-chemical parameters (rs=0.673; p=0.002) and (rs=0.637; p=0.003), which is a clear indication of the impact of brine disposal from both plants on the marine environment. For most of coastal desalination plants on the Libyan coastline, the most practical and least expensive brine disposal option is to discharge it into the sea. It is necessary therefore, to effectively manage desalination reject brine in order to ensure more efficient disposal and reuse. Therefore, it is suggested that experimental studies are aimed for dual benefit of on-site generation of sodium hypochlorite through brine electrolysis and to recover minerals and NaCl from the brine using evaporation ponds, while protecting the environment. Following the first experiment, the outcome of brine utilisation showed a significant production of NaOCl using graphite electrodes (MCCA 1.82 gr/m3). At interelectrode spacing 2 cm and 4 cm, the power consumption was higher, with a greater concentration of sodium hypochlorite generation varying between 10-25 kw/m3 (573-2140ppm) and 29-24 kwm-3 (572-2600ppm) than at interelectrode spacing 6cm 17-13 kwm-3 (350-1790ppm). Consequently, the selection of an optimum electrical consumption level is key in establishing the best scenario in terms of economy and efficiency. Subsequent to the second experiment of brine evaporation in the ponds, results showed that the evaporation rate in August was lower than in September (9.06 mmday-1, 14.63 mmday-1) respectively. The results of the SEM/EDS test showed that due to elevated surges of Na+ and Cl-, halite (NaCl) was the main mineral evident during crystallisation of the salt samples. Hence, the two experiments reveal that brine can be recycled productively, while protecting the environment.

  • Conference Article
  • Cite Count Icon 1
  • 10.1063/5.0059482
Minireview: Membrane forward osmosis as alternative method in water treatment
  • Jan 1, 2021
  • Saiful + 2 more

Water scarcity and limited water access for the community have encouraged the development of various technologies to facilitate access to various water sources in nature. Sea and brackish water desalination are the fastest and comfortable to meet growing water needs. The forward osmosis membranes is an alternative method for removing salt and impurity compounds both in brackish water and seawater to replace the reverse osmosis process in desalination of seawater and brackish water which are cheaper and environmentally friendly. A number of successes have been achieved in preparing FO membranes. Membranes can be made from either natural polymers or synthetic polymers. FO membrane performance improvement is still a challenge that researchers must continue to study and the challenges in implementing FO membranes on a large scale still face problems in the field that need to be overcome. In this paper discuss advance in FO membrane for seawater and brackish water desalination.

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 65
  • 10.1016/s0011-9164(03)00397-7
Desalination of brackish water by nanofiltration and reverse osmosis
  • Aug 1, 2003
  • Desalination
  • Mousa S Mohsen + 2 more

Desalination of brackish water by nanofiltration and reverse osmosis

Save Icon
Up Arrow
Open/Close
  • Ask R Discovery Star icon
  • Chat PDF Star icon

AI summaries and top papers from 250M+ research sources.

Search IconWhat is the difference between bacteria and viruses?
Open In New Tab Icon
Search IconWhat is the function of the immune system?
Open In New Tab Icon
Search IconCan diabetes be passed down from one generation to the next?
Open In New Tab Icon