Sea level muon spectrum derived from the primary nucleon spectrum using the Cocconi–Koester–Perkins model

Abstract

In a recent paper Sarkar, Bhattacharyya, and Basu have derived the sea level muon energy spectrum from the measured nucleon spectrum of Ryan, Ormes, and Balasubrahmanyan using the Cocconi–Koester–Perkins model. They have found good agreement between this muon spectrum and the precisely measured spectrum of Ayre, Baxendale, Hume, Nandi, Thompson, and Whalley. In this report a critical analysis of the paper has been made and it is found that there are some obvious mistakes both in the formulation and in the calculation. The corrected results do not agree with the Ayre et al. spectrum. The unjustified values of some of the parameters used in their work are discussed.