Sc(III) porphyrins. The molecular structure of two Sc(III) porphyrins and a re-evaluation of the parameters for the molecular mechanics modelling of Sc(III) porphyrins

Abstract

The crystal structures of two new Sc(III) porphyrins, [Sc(TPP)Cl]·2.5(1-chloronaphthalene), (5,10,15,20-tetraphenylporphyrin)-chloro-scandium(III)·2.5(1-chloronaphthalene) solvate, (Mo Kα, 0.71073 Å, triclinic system P 1 ¯ , a = 9.9530(2) Å, b = 15.4040(3) Å, c = 17.7770(3) Å, α = 86.5190(10)°, β = 89.7680(10)°, γ = 86.9720(10)°, 13101 independent reflections, R 1 = 0.0712) and the dimeric [μ 2-(OH) 2(Sc(TPP)) 2], bis-(μ-hydroxo)-(5,10,15,20-tetraphenylporphyrin) scandium(III) (Mo Kα, 0.71073 Å, monoclinic system C2, a = 24.2555(16) Å, b = 11.1598(7) Å, c = 25.6468(17) Å, β = 91.980(2)°, 13084 independent reflections, R 1 = 0.0485) are reported. In [Sc(TPP)Cl] the metal is five-coordinate and the porphyrin is domed with the metal displaced by 0.63 Å from the mean porphyrin towards the axial Cl − ligand. The average Sc–N bond length is 2.143(3) Å, which is shorter than the average bond length of previously reported structures. Two of the phenyl rings are nearly orthogonal to the porphyrin core and the other two are significantly tilted because of contacts with 1-chloronaphthalene solvent molecules, and the phenyl rings of neighbouring porphyrins. In [μ 2-(OH) 2(Sc(TPP)) 2] both porphyrins are domed, with the metal displaced from the mean porphyrin plane towards the bridging hydroxo ligands. The average Sc–N bond length is 2.197(12) Å, which is in the upper range of Sc–N bond lengths in known Sc(III) porphyrins but not dissimilar to the average Sc–N bond lengths in another other bis-μ 2-hydroxo Sc(III) porphyrin, [μ 2-(OH) 2(Sc(OEP)) 2]. One porphyrin is rotated relative to the upper porphyrin by 25° due to steric contacts between the phenyl substituents. We have used these new structures to re-evaluated our previously reported molecular mechanics force field parameters for modelling Sc(III) porphyrins using the MM2 force field; the training set was augmented from two to seven structures by using all available Sc(III) porphyrin structures and the two new structures. The modelling reproduces the porphyrin core very accurately; bond lengths are reproduced to within 0.01 Å, bond angles to within 0.5° and torsional angles to within 2°. The optimum parameters for modelling the Sc(III)–N bond lengths, determined by finding the minimum difference between the crystallographic and modelling mean bond lengths with the aid of artificial neural network architectures, were found to be 0.90 ± 0.03 mdyn Å −1 for the bond force constant and2.005 ± 0.005 Å for the strain-free bond length. Modelling the seven Sc(III) porphyrins with the new parameters gives an average Sc–N bond length of 2.182 ± 0.018 Å, indistinguishable from the crystallographic mean of 2.181 ± 0.024 Å.