Scale-dependent patterns of fish faunal homogenization in Neotropical reservoirs

Abstract

The conservation challenges facing freshwater ecosystems necessitate broadening our science from understanding individual species loss to anticipating multi-faceted changes to biodiversity. In recent decades, the process of biotic homogenization by which regional biotas become more similar through time has attracted considerable attention. Here, we (1) quantified spatial and temporal changes in taxonomic and functional similarity of fish assemblages among Neotropical reservoirs, (2) determined nonnative species contributions to changes in taxonomic and functional composition, and (3) evaluated relationships between the changes in taxonomic and functional similarity among reservoirs. We did so by considering different spatial scales: inter- and intra-ecoregions. At inter-ecoregion scale, reservoir fish assemblages have become taxonomically homogenized over time, whereas functional trait composition has tended to differentiate. At intra-ecoregion scale, we detected both taxonomic and functional differentiation over time. Despite these overall trends, different ecoregions exhibited considerable variation in patterns of fish faunal homogenization and differentiation. We found a moderate positive relationship between changes in mean taxonomic and functional similarity among reservoirs at inter-ecoregion scale, which was no longer evident within ecoregions. In conclusion, this study demonstrates the strong scale-dependence of perceived patterns in homogenization, and further highlights the magnitude of threats to freshwater biodiversity in the Neotropical ecosystems.