Scalable storyboards in handheld devices: applications and evaluation metrics

Abstract

Summaries are an essential component of video retrieval and browsing systems. Most research in video summarization has focused on content analysis to obtain compact yet comprehensive representations of video items. However, important aspects such as how they can be effectively integrated in mobile interfaces and how to predict the quality and usability of the summaries have not been investigated. Conventional summaries are limited to a single instance with certain length (i.e. a single scale). In contrast, scalable summaries target representations with multiple scales, that is, a set of summaries with increasing length in which longer summaries include more information about the video. Thus, scalability provides high flexibility that can be exploited in devices such as smartphones or tablets to provide versions of the summary adapted to the limited visualization area. In this paper, we explore the application of scalable storyboards to summary adaptation and zoomable video navigation in handheld devices. By introducing a new adaptation dimension related with the summarization scale, we can formulate navigation and adaptation in a two-dimensional adaptation space, where different navigation actions modify the trajectory in that space. We also describe the challenges to evaluate scalable summaries and some usability issues that arise from having multiple scales, proposing some objective metrics that can provide useful insight about their potential quality and usability without requiring very costly user studies. Experimental results show a reasonable agreement with the trends shown in subjective evaluations. Experiments also show that content-based scalable storyboards are less redundant and useful than the content-blind baselines.