Satisfaction, control and pain relief: short- and long-term assessments in a randomised controlled trial of low-dose and traditional epidurals and a non-epidural comparison group

Abstract

Background Childbirth is an important life event for which a positive experience is important to many women. Methods As secondary outcomes from the randomised controlled Comparative Obstetric Mobile Epidural Trial, various aspects of satisfaction were assessed in women who had one of three types of regional analgesia (two of which were low-dose techniques and a high-dose control using 0.25% epidural bupivacaine) and a comparison group who did not have epidural analgesia, shortly after delivery and 12 months later. Results The predominant finding was satisfaction with spontaneous vaginal delivery whatever the mode of analgesia. The overall immediate and long-term satisfaction was similar for all three neuraxial techniques. Satisfaction with the speed of pain relief and the amount of mobility were significantly greater for the combined spinal-epidural technique compared with the low-dose infusion ( P<0.001). The degree of control felt by women who had combined spinal-epidural analgesia was greater than with the high-dose ( P<0.05). Women in the non-epidural comparison group did not report a greater feeling of control. Among those who delivered spontaneously, more women in the combined spinal-epidural group (30%) felt in full control compared with the high-dose group (17%) ( P<0.05). By comparison 22% in the low-dose infusion group and only 15% who had no epidural felt in full control. Conclusions Whilst satisfaction with the experience of childbirth appears intimately related to the attainment of a spontaneous delivery, mobile epidurals enhance women’s feeling of control in labour and are popular for future choice of regional analgesia.