Sanger-based sequencing technology for yellow fever vaccine genetic quality control

Abstract

Yellow Fever (YF) is an acute viral hemorrhagic disease prevalent mainly in Africa and Americas, with 20–60% fatality rate in severe forms. Currently, antiviral drugs for the infection are not available, reinforcing the importance of vaccination in resident populations and travelers. Manufactured in 7 different countries, the YF vaccine was first created in 1937 and two substrains are used for production, 17DD and 17D-204. The vaccine produced in Bio-Manguinhos/Brazil uses 17DD substrain and more than 160 million doses have been exported to over 74 countries. The World Health Organization (WHO) recommends that new seed- and working-lots should have the viral genome sequenced in order to check vaccine genetic stability. The aim of this study was to develop and standardize a Sanger-based sequencing protocol for the genetic monitoring of the Brazilian 17DD vaccine. We designed 54 oligos to access the complete YF vaccine genome by RT-PCR and sequencing approach. After protocol standardization, we tested 45 vaccine lots and the corresponding secondary and working seed lots. All 45 lots presented 100% nucleotide identity to each other and to the seed lots. We also detected 2 heterogeneous positions at nucleotides 4523 (C/T) and 6673 (C/T) that may indicate a quasispecies diversity of YF 17DD strain. When compared to the Brazilian GenBank sequence YFU17066, the Brazilian 17DD vaccine presented 6 silent mutations. By applying the sequencing methodology to two YF 17D-204 strains, we showed that our method can also be used to sequence different YF vaccine virus. In summary, we have developed a robust method for the genetic monitoring of YF vaccines, which has been successfully applied in Bio-Manguinhos since 2009 and could also be used by other manufacturers for YF17D-based vaccines. There were no genetic variation in the Brazilian tested lots, highlighting the safety, production consistency and, more importantly, the genetic stability of Bio-Manguinhos’ YF vaccine in the last 3 decades.