Salt Marsh Plant Zonation: The Relative Importance of Competition and Physical Factors

Abstract

In Carpinteria Salt Marsh, Salicornia virginica (pickleweed) grows at lower marsh elevations than does Arthrocnemum subterminalis (Parish's glasswort). Standing biomass of both species was greatest immediately adjacent to their abrupt border, suggesting that conditions for plant growth were best here. We utilized field experiments, in which growth rates of naturally occurring and transplanted individuals of both species were measured in four marsh zones, to investigate the role of edaphic factors and competition in maintaining this zonation pattern. The frequency of flooding, and hence soil waterlogging, was greatest at lower marsh elevations, whereas salinity was highest at higher marsh elevations. Consequently, it was not clear, a priori, which part of the marsh had the most severe physical conditions. In our field experiments, both Salicornia and Arthrocnemum grew better in the two middle marsh zones (high Salicornia zone and Arthrocnemum zone) than in either the low marsh (low Salicornia zone), where flooding was frequent and soils were waterlogged, or the high marsh (transition zone), where soil salinity was extremely high during much of the year and plant water potentials very low. However, Salicornia appeared better able to tolerate flooding, and so persisted in the low Salicornia zone, whereas Arthrocnemum appeared better able to tolerate high salinities, and so persisted in the transition zone. Interspecific competition was most important in the relatively benign middle marsh zones, where each species excluded the other from a portion of this prime habitat. In this marsh, flooding, soil salinity, and competition all interacted to determine plant zonation patterns, but the relative importance of these factors varied at different elevations.