Salmon sperm DNA increases sample recovery from cotton swabs

Abstract

Forensic samples with low DNA template amounts are difficult to analyze and interpret. There is a large body of research demonstrating that adding carrier nucleic acid to storage tubes, solid phase extractions, or filtering devices can improve yields of target DNA. However, the addition of carrier nucleic acid to sampling substrates, like cotton swabs, has not yet been attempted. In this proof-of-concept study, carrier nucleic acids in the form of either Poly (A) RNA or salmon sperm DNA were spotted onto cotton swabs, followed by human genomic DNA, to determine if introducing the carrier prior to sample collection would increase recovery from the swabs post-extraction. Extracts were also evaluated to determine whether adding the carrier nucleic acids to human DNA would interfere with downstream forensic DNA analysis processes such as real-time PCR quantitation, PCR amplification of STR loci, or capillary electrophoresis. The RNA carrier did not improve human sample recovery from cotton swabs. The extraction efficiency of human DNA from cotton swabs was increased when the DNA carrier was applied to the swabs prior to sample deposition, and the scale of the increase depended on the amount of carrier DNA used. When applying the salmon sperm DNA carrier to cotton swabs, with each increase from no carrier to 0.001–1–10 µg, human DNA recovery went from ∼29 % to ∼50 % to ∼75 % to ∼100 %. Additionally, no inhibitory effects from the carrier DNA were observed post-extraction with quantitation or in the DNA profile after amplification. Therefore, salmon sperm DNA carrier will increase human DNA yield from cotton swabs without negative effects on downstream forensic DNA profiling methods, with the optimal carrier amount being 10 µg.