Saline and hydrocarbon-bearing fluids detected in shallow aquifers of southern New Brunswick, Canada: Natural occurrence, or deep migration along faults and industrial wellbores?

Abstract

Unconventional hydrocarbon production has sparked public concerns for several years, especially regarding potential potable groundwater contamination by hydrocarbons, brines, and various chemicals related to hydraulic fracturing operations. One possible contamination mechanism is upward migration of deep-seated contaminants over large vertical distances, through preferential pathways such as leaky well casings or permeable geological faults. In New Brunswick (Canada), thermogenic hydrocarbons and brackish water were previously reported in shallow water wells, some of them located close to unconventional gas wells or to major faults, but the exact origin of these fluids remained uncertain. The objective of this paper is to determine whether the presence of these fluids is the result of migration from the deep (>1 km) hydrocarbon bearing units (via natural or anthropogenic migration pathways), or whether they rather originate within the shallow aquifer (<100 m) or from intermediate zone . Tracking fluid origin was achieved by fingerprinting compositional and isotopic values of three indicators: 1) water isotopic signature (including tritium (3H), radiocarbon (14CDIC), δ18OH2O, δ2HH2O), 2) salinity (including Na, Ca, K, SO4, Cl, Br, 87Sr/86Sr), and 3) hydrocarbons (compositional data and δ13CCH4). These various analyses were conducted, when relevant, on samples of different matrices composing the hydrogeological system, namely shallow groundwater (12–90 m depth), shallow bedrock gas (8–131 m), and intermediate zone evaporitic rocks (173–332 m); they were compared with previously published values for deep basin brines and gases (1940–3168 m) from the hydrocarbon bearing Carboniferous Albert Formation. This unique suite of indicators, analytes and matrices allowed drawing the conclusion that thermogenic gas and high salinities present in the sampled wells were naturally occurring and originating from shallow and intermediate-zone bedrock units. Results obtained through this approach did not provide any evidence that hydrocarbon wells in this area have acted as preferential migration pathways for deep-seated fluids towards shallow aquifers.