Safety net, gateway, market, sport, and war: Exploring how emergency physicians conceptualize and ascribe meaning to emergency care

Abstract

BackgroundMetaphorical expressions and conceptualisations are widely used in medical discourse to convey complex and abstract concepts. Our study uses a novel way to examine the spontaneous use of metaphors by emergency physicians as they articulate their experiences of practicing emergency care. These co-constructions shed light on the values and beliefs that shape their emergency care practice. MethodsWe invited 25 Taiwanese emergency physicians to participate in one-to-one semi-structured interviews. ResultsDrawing on social constructionism theory, systematic metaphor analysis method and Metaphor Identification Procedure (MIP) we identified metaphorical linguistic expressions in their talk, grouping them into five-overarching conceptual metaphors. We argue that these metaphors underpin emergency physicians’ experiences of practicing emergency medical care: Safety Net, Gateway, Market, War, and Sport. DiscussionThe Safety Net, Gateway, and Market conceptualisations highlight physician-patient relationships and the social mission, resource allocation, and consumerism aspects of emergency care practice. The Sport and War conceptualisations highlight the physician–physician relationship and the demanding, team-based nature of emergency care practice. ConclusionWe propose that the choice of metaphorical conceptualisation deployed by emergency physicians has implications on their embodiment of professional identities. This discussion of using metaphors to study professional identities contributes to the literature concerned with finding creative and innovative ways to research identities. Future studies may utilize metaphors to gain a comprehensive understanding of physicians’ professional identities in other specialties.