Runoff, erosion and sediment particle size from smooth and rough soil surfaces under steady rainfall-runoff conditions

Abstract

The responses of runoff and erosion to soil surface roughness (SSR) have been extensively studied in the past decades; however, most of these studies were conducted at the early stage of rainfall, whereas few studies were specifically conducted during steady runoff conditions. In this study, runoff, soil losses and sediment particle sizes from smooth and rough surfaces were measured after surface runoff stabilisation to improve the understanding of the relationship between SSR and soil erosion. A cascade of two independent soil boxes in which the runoff samples from upslope and downslope boxes can be collected independently or together was used to perform the experiments. The upslope box supplied runoff to the downslope study box. Three rainfall intensities of 50, 75 and 100 mm/h were applied. The results suggest that SSR has a significant effect on soil erosion when runoff reaches a steady state. Although the difference in the runoff rate was small between the rough and smooth surfaces, the sediment rate and concentration of particles were significantly lower for the rough surface than for the smooth surface. Through analysing the particle size distribution (PSD) of sediment, we found that selective sediment delivery is an important reason for the soil erosion reduction by SSR. The rainfall intensity decreased the difference in the sediment rates between the smooth and rough surfaces. The extra inflow increased the runoff rates, sediment rates and concentration rates for both the smooth and rough surfaces; however, the increasing degrees of the runoff rate, sediment rate and concentration rate had significant differences between the rough and smooth surfaces. A stepwise multiple regression showed that significant linear relationships existed between one or more PSDs of 20–50, 50–100, 100–250 and 1000–2000 µm and the sediment rate.